CuriousDish: Which Dallas Restaurant Would You Revive?

Let’s take a break from the restaurants still here and think about those that we miss. Imagine you had the power–a genie in a bottle of Chateau Latour Pomerol to grant you one wish. If you could rub her it and be granted the gift to bring one dead restaurant back to life, which one would you revive and why?  Riviera? Routh Street? Nero’s?

UPDATE: After roughly 24 hours, over 100 Dishers had asked their genies to revive their favorite restaurants!! Let’s dig through and see.  After 146 genie rubs, Lola gets the most requests, at 8.  Lots of love for Il Sorrento with 6 rubs and Cuidad at 5.  The Wine Press and Uncle Tai’s had 4 mentions.  Surprises for me included Routh Street and The Riviera only getting one comment each.  Lots of love spread out for Stephan Pyles’ concepts including Baby Routh (3), Star Canyon (3), and Aquaknox (2).

120 comments

  1. Without question: Cafe Marrakesh in Richardson. Best Moroccan food in the city.

    @ 9:58 am on August 24, 2010
  2. Actuelle?

    @ 10:03 am on August 24, 2010
  3. Alo – that wonderful place owned by the La Duni folks. The food was unique and the restaurant beautiful – burned a year ago and despite initial promises it would be brought back, we have seen nothing materialize.

    @ 10:10 am on August 24, 2010
  4. 2900.

    @ 10:11 am on August 24, 2010
  5. Roasters.

    @ 10:12 am on August 24, 2010
  6. A long time ago there was a Caribbean restaurant on lower greenville.

    @ 10:14 am on August 24, 2010
  7. Lola. For the wine list & atmosphere as much as the food.

    @ 10:17 am on August 24, 2010
  8. Uncle Tai’s

    @ 10:26 am on August 24, 2010
  9. The name escapes me but the italian restaurant that was on Hillcrest and Northwest Highway with the indoor Canal and Gaudy Italian Street Scene

    @ 10:29 am on August 24, 2010
  10. Il Sorrento

    @ 10:37 am on August 24, 2010
  11. Il Sorrento was the Italian restaurant on NW Hwy & Hillcrest.
    I would love to eat at Cayuse again. I thought it was Monica’s best…..alas I must have been in the great minority!!!!!

    @ 10:38 am on August 24, 2010
  12. Both of mine were already mentioned but for sure – Alo and 2900.

    @ 10:39 am on August 24, 2010
  13. La Tosca where Shinsei now is…authentic, true Italian…

    Il Sorrento, just because it was great times

    @ 10:41 am on August 24, 2010
  14. Soley on Henderson.

    @ 10:50 am on August 24, 2010
  15. Little Gus’s!

    @ 10:52 am on August 24, 2010
  16. Holy Smokes and Big D’s Dog, RIP.

    @ 10:53 am on August 24, 2010
  17. On the higher end, I would be happy to see the return of Toscana at McKinney and Monticello.

    On the lower end, I miss Chip’s at Knox & Armstrong. The ambiance (and accessibility) at the Lover’s Lane location is just not the same.

    @ 10:56 am on August 24, 2010
  18. Kobawoo. Small Korean BBQ joint on Inwood in a bombed-out strip mall, run by a mom and pop who hardly spoke any English and fronted by their son who did. It was a great little hole in the wall, the first one that my wife and I shared really fondly. I’ve always thought that the strip mall was probably burned by its owner for the insurance money because Kobawoo was the only thing in it except for a really nasty c-store. I think there’s a Taco Bell there now.

    @ 10:56 am on August 24, 2010
  19. What was the asian fusion restaurant on McKinney where La Duni is now? It had all those origami cranes hanging from the ceiling and the best pot stickers.

    @ 11:03 am on August 24, 2010
  20. Toscana and Ill Sorrento.

    One for food and one for mood. And the palm reading!!

    @ 11:09 am on August 24, 2010
  21. @Amy S … Anzu’s, where I pulled up, and as we got out, my date told me in no uncertain terms: “I don’t each sushi”. Nevertheless, I married her two years later.

    @ 11:16 am on August 24, 2010
  22. Ditto Little Gus, and also Ruby’s that followed it.
    Savino, on Henderson
    Ciudad
    Ratcliffe’s
    Flip’s
    Juniper (before Lola was Lola)

    @ 11:27 am on August 24, 2010
  23. Ricardo’s Tex-Mex in Allen was very good. Were opening at a new location but never did.

    @ 11:38 am on August 24, 2010
  24. The original Kirby’s Steakhouse and Railhead Steakhouse. For our high school prom dinner, a group of us went to Ports O’ Call.

    @ 11:43 am on August 24, 2010
  25. Only one !? Here’s my list; in order.
    1. Enclave supper club, on Walnut Hill
    2. Lola
    3. Ciudad

    @ 11:45 am on August 24, 2010
  26. El Taxco, Moctezuma’s, Victoria Station

    @ 11:46 am on August 24, 2010
  27. Citizen or Knox Street Pub

    @ 11:52 am on August 24, 2010
  28. Baby Doe’s Matchless Mine for the view and unique building and location if nothing else.
    Kip’s Big Boy had the best french toast ever.

    @ 12:02 pm on August 24, 2010
  29. Definitely Cuidad!!! We’ve been searching hi and low for a brunch like that it’s just not to be found. Dinner was also fantastic. Great atmosphere, great people. Hint, hint, Monica!

    @ 12:03 pm on August 24, 2010
  30. Did I just say “hi” and low? Forgive me.

    @ 12:03 pm on August 24, 2010
  31. Lemmon Avenue Bar and Grill

    @ 12:04 pm on August 24, 2010
  32. Baby Doe’s.

    @ 12:08 pm on August 24, 2010
  33. There’s a “chateau latour a pomerol” but I think you are referring to “chateau latour pauillac”

    $10 says martin scorsese up there is AC. [Ed note: a portion of this comment has been removed. Keep it civil, please.]

    @ 12:19 pm on August 24, 2010
  34. La Dolce Vita
    Liberty Noodles
    Nero’s
    Dan’s in Lakewood– I know it was gross. I mostly want to see it again (preferably in a time machine set to winter of 1998) not eat there.

    @ 12:28 pm on August 24, 2010
  35. Il Grano up in Plano. I still can’t believe they turned it into an On the Border Express.

    @ 12:35 pm on August 24, 2010
  36. Southern Kitchen, if only for those delicious cinnamon rolls.

    @ 12:39 pm on August 24, 2010
  37. Enigma. Because it was.

    @ 12:40 pm on August 24, 2010
  38. Enigma was indeed a funny place. We were seated at a table placed inside a king sized bed frame. The waiter tripped (but recovered gracefully) as he stepped over with our food.

    @ 12:55 pm on August 24, 2010
  39. The Wine Press, 8.0 in the Quadrangle, Queen of Sheba on McKinney (by the Loon); Baby Routh. Kinda miss Star Canyon, too.

    @ 12:56 pm on August 24, 2010
  40. Roasters
    Lola
    Liberty
    Newport’s
    Aquaknox (before it started to suck)
    Fusion
    Alo
    Buster’s

    @ 1:00 pm on August 24, 2010
  41. The old Sonny Bryan’s location on Jefferson in Oak Cliff, so I could taste good BBQ at a Sonny Bryan’s location.

    @ 1:03 pm on August 24, 2010
  42. One? Well, probably Citizen only because the food was so good and my departed Daddy said “I’ll take the #27″ to which the server replied “Um, sir, that’s the price.”) I also had a series of amazing first dates during my 20′s at Flip’s (first taste of port among other things).

    @ 1:09 pm on August 24, 2010
  43. Il sorrento.

    @ 1:11 pm on August 24, 2010
  44. Voltaire

    @ 1:14 pm on August 24, 2010
  45. Definitely Uncle Tai’s.

    @ 1:15 pm on August 24, 2010
  46. Chips . Chips. Chips. the one on Cole.

    @ 1:19 pm on August 24, 2010
  47. I thought I was the only one who remembered Enigmna. It was quirky restaurant, but I think I dined there no less than 20 times. The tables and plate settings were amazing, the service doting. Thanks, TLS.

    @ 1:28 pm on August 24, 2010
  48. Hola’s! Best Tapas restaurant in Dallas last 10 years

    @ 1:34 pm on August 24, 2010
  49. I’m going to go against common sense and, perhaps, common decency and suggest the return of a steakhouse. Smith & Wollensky’s on the Tollway was the only steakhouse in Dallas to give Pappas a run for its money (well, figuratively). Steak for steak, side for side, dessert for dessert, I preferred Smith & Wollensky’s every step of the way.

    Of course, if I wanted it bad enough, I could always drive down to Houston, but I’d much rather have it here in town.

    @ 1:38 pm on August 24, 2010
  50. ditto little gus’s
    La Cave, particularly the west end location
    Wine Press on Oak Lawn
    Pantelli’s (my favorite of all time)

    @ 1:45 pm on August 24, 2010
  51. Lola’s. The food, the wine list, the location.

    I still miss it.

    @ 1:47 pm on August 24, 2010
  52. Los Vaqueros!

    @ 1:56 pm on August 24, 2010
  53. Ratcliffe’s (best poached salmon), Gershwins’s (mainly for the bar), Il Sorrento (for the hokiness), the Italian deli-type place on Lower Greenville (can’t remember the name), Mad Hatters (best cheeseburgers!), and Holy Cow (hot fudge pie) and, of course, Terrillis!

    @ 2:06 pm on August 24, 2010
  54. Il Sorrento – loved how cheesy it was, the piano player and the tarot card reader (she was scary accurate!)
    La Cave- Henderson location. I find myself wanting to go there now- decent, well priced wine , with french bistro atmosphere and great staff. Also, so fun for Bastille day!

    @ 2:23 pm on August 24, 2010
  55. Litos

    @ 2:26 pm on August 24, 2010
  56. Barclay’s
    Cheslea (?) pizza place on McKinney
    Chapman Chile Kitchen
    New Mexican place where Sevy’s is now

    @ 2:28 pm on August 24, 2010
  57. La Valentina in Addison. Best Mole’ in a restaurant!

    @ 2:30 pm on August 24, 2010
  58. Cuquitas on Henderson. Great for a nacho fix at 2:30 in the morning.

    @ 2:32 pm on August 24, 2010
  59. Oh, man. Let me just say, ALL THE ABOVE!

    @ 2:33 pm on August 24, 2010
  60. sams cafe and canyon cafe. come on, people!

    @ 2:44 pm on August 24, 2010
  61. Baby Ruth. The Wine Press. Lombardi Mare

    @ 2:48 pm on August 24, 2010
  62. Enclave
    Papayon
    Lalowe
    Chateau Briand
    La Sayson
    Mories
    Pierre’s
    Cafe Passfic
    Cupccino
    They were all Five Star,i am sorry for
    spelling their name

    @ 2:56 pm on August 24, 2010
  63. The Railhead was it back in the day!

    @ 3:22 pm on August 24, 2010
  64. ALO–briefly in the shopping center on the southwest corner of Central @ Knox before it burned. It was so fabulous (is that what you are talking about BorntoRhone?)

    @ 3:26 pm on August 24, 2010
  65. Gennie’s Bishop Grill.

    @ 3:29 pm on August 24, 2010
  66. Marty’s on Oak Lawn. It was the perfect neighborhood place, nice without being stuffy or pretentious. And wonderful food as well.

    @ 3:29 pm on August 24, 2010
  67. Tarantino’s in Fair Park. First date with my wife.
    Flying Burro on lower Greenville.
    Nuevo Leon.

    @ 3:33 pm on August 24, 2010
  68. Lombardi Mare.

    @ 3:41 pm on August 24, 2010
  69. Zider Zee (Inwood and Denton Road area)
    Youngblood’s (Preston and Forest)
    The Torch (Oak Cliff)
    the original Ojeda’s (old house on Maple)
    Ok, so I’m old.

    @ 4:12 pm on August 24, 2010
  70. Oz
    Jean Claude’s
    Calluaud’s
    The Rib
    Southern Kitchen
    Routh Street

    @ 4:13 pm on August 24, 2010
  71. Uncle Tai’s
    Rooster’s on Lemmon where Manny’s is
    Liberty Noodle
    Holy Smokes

    @ 4:22 pm on August 24, 2010
  72. Jamie’s Hamburgers Lemon Ave
    Youngblood’s Fry Chicken various locations.
    Little bit of Sweden Inwood plaza

    Now for a out there “The Shed” if you are old enough to remember! All you can eat steak.

    @ 4:27 pm on August 24, 2010
  73. Steak & Ale (God I miss that place!)

    @ 4:33 pm on August 24, 2010
  74. Mmm representing Cowtown on this one… Angeluna.

    @ 4:34 pm on August 24, 2010
  75. Oh my, I just got caught up. I am in tears over some of these places. Oz! I have a call in to chef Jean LaFont. Hopefully we can do a little salute to Oz. Oh, it was yar.

    @ 4:36 pm on August 24, 2010
  76. Kitchen 1924 in Lakewood… I miss that pork chop

    @ 4:39 pm on August 24, 2010
  77. So many – can’t name just one!

    The White Swan
    La Tosca
    Chaplain’s
    Nuevo Leon
    The “original” On the Border (Knox)
    Soley
    Il Sole
    Lola
    Meditteraneo
    Bishop Arts Cafe

    @ 5:41 pm on August 24, 2010
  78. Lots of places and lots of good memories but loved Baby Routh and Jamie’s Hamburgers. But Alo? One of the worst, stupidests disaters in Dallas dining. The only thing that made them was the blessed fire.

    @ 5:50 pm on August 24, 2010
  79. Litos, La Palapa Veracruzana.

    @ 5:55 pm on August 24, 2010
  80. Blue’s Lake Front – Cheese broccoli soup and the onion rings
    Guadalaja’s – A pitcher of frozen margarita’s please
    La Suprema’s on Military Parkway – The best chips and salsa
    The Brisket – Big schooner of Schlitz to go with that BBQ

    @ 6:30 pm on August 24, 2010
  81. Ciudad
    Aquaknox

    @ 6:34 pm on August 24, 2010
  82. I also miss the original Sambuca in Deep Ellum. It made me feel like I was at an intimate jazz club in NYC which happened to have solid Mediterranean food. The new one on Pearl just does not compare (for ambiance or food).

    @ 7:13 pm on August 24, 2010
  83. Anyone know how to get ahold of the tarot reader at Il Sorrento? She was awesome and I would like to hire her for an event!

    @ 7:34 pm on August 24, 2010
  84. @tinkerbell

    Carmela just turned 90, the card reader @ Il Sorrento. She lives @ Preston Towers condos.

    She’s often hanging around the lobby waiting for a driver to take her shopping.

    not sure if she still reads cards, but there you have it.

    @ 7:44 pm on August 24, 2010
  85. There are two that I still miss:
    1. Fog City Diner, and
    2. The Rusty Pelican (Sunday Brunch).

    One runner up would be Ciao II at the Centrum. Good times were had at all of them :)

    @ 7:49 pm on August 24, 2010
  86. Charco’s hamburgers on Mockingbird
    The Beggers Club
    Casa Domingez, Ate my first Nacho there
    Youngbloods
    Kips wedge salad
    Shakey’s Pizza
    Zuider Zee , Our family looked forward to lobster week all year
    Jay’s seafood
    Jamil’s steakhouse
    Dean’s seafood
    Trader Vic’s OOOPPS!! we already tried that
    Anything at European Crossroads

    @ 7:56 pm on August 24, 2010
  87. For Dependable Continental: Mr. Pepe’s
    For Fun: Caruso’s (budding opera stars, booths with doors, bottomless wine glass, Italian comfort food)
    For a Quick Trip to France: La Cave
    For An Incredible Experience Every Time: Lola

    @ 7:58 pm on August 24, 2010
  88. to this day, I’ve never had a better steak than at the Railhead.

    @ 8:05 pm on August 24, 2010
  89. Riviera was the best.

    @ 8:36 pm on August 24, 2010
  90. Ewald’s

    @ 9:28 pm on August 24, 2010
  91. Lucas B&B anyone? It was so long ago I don’t remember if the food was good, it just was a great place.

    @ 10:42 pm on August 24, 2010
  92. Salve. I’m sad and will never forget those dinners. I still love Sharon and consider her one of the gems of Dallas.

    Lola, Van’s impeccable service and insane wine list were hard to beat anywhere…

    @ 12:41 am on August 25, 2010
  93. Uncle Tais (would love to know of another Chinese place as good)
    Strictly tabu. Great jazz and pizza
    Cactus Jacks
    Gilberts Deli

    @ 2:18 am on August 25, 2010
  94. Ha. I drink beer on occasion with the last owner of Strictly Tabu. Dutch is a great guy and sings a mean karaoke. He also has the best seats for Mav’s. Bring it back? He should.

    @ 3:22 am on August 25, 2010
  95. The PUB in Nordstrom’s! Hands down had the best upscale bar food around….

    @ 7:01 am on August 25, 2010
  96. The italian restaurant at the old Barneys.. What was the name?? Fantastic.

    Goldfingers

    The original Chili’s on Greenville and Meadow (long before it became Brinkerized

    @ 8:16 am on August 25, 2010
  97. Matt’s No Place in Lakewood, and The Wine Press. Cafe Society…… It was waaaay ahead of its time. Andrew’s on McKinney.

    @ 8:48 am on August 25, 2010
  98. Oops forgot to mention the original Kirby’s. A great place to impress the girls in High School.

    @ 9:41 am on August 25, 2010
  99. Filling Station on Greenville – loved that place, but probably better for me to not eat there….

    Royal Tokyo on Greenville had all the charm of an authentic Japanese restaurant, not like Benihana.

    I wish HP Cafeteria was the same….but that Casa Linda remake doesn’t cut it.

    @ 9:43 am on August 25, 2010
  100. Lola- When Jamie Samford was there(where is he now?)
    Green Room- When Marc Cassel was there
    Matt’s No Place
    A and W Root Beer on Spring Valley and the Tollway.

    @ 9:51 am on August 25, 2010
  101. Prince of Hamburgers on Lemmon

    @ 11:19 am on August 25, 2010
  102. Matt’s No Place and Ciudad are great suggestions. I go with Star Canyon (with Stephen Pyles) – best chicken I’ve had in my life and the first upscale Dallas restaurant I visited.

    @ 12:01 pm on August 25, 2010
  103. Strictly Taboo. Oh yeah!!

    @ 12:53 pm on August 25, 2010
  104. Nancy…is this a record for the number of replies?

    @ 12:54 pm on August 25, 2010
  105. Max, Jamie Samford is now the executive chef at the Cowboys Stadium in Arlington.

    @ 1:29 pm on August 25, 2010
  106. Dallas needs another Strictly Taboo!!!!!

    @ 1:33 pm on August 25, 2010
  107. Record number of replies is 235 for Casey Thompson. I think.

    @ 1:34 pm on August 25, 2010
  108. you have to have been around for awhile, but there was a great place on Bachman Lake in the mid to late 70′s called The Clam Digger – wonderful seafood and especially the shrimp.

    Let’s not forget the theme restaurant that always had a great night crowd – Randy Tarr on upper Greenville

    @ 2:37 pm on August 25, 2010
  109. Don’t we have to admit that Sfuzzi proves that you can never really go home again?
    Of course, I’m holding out hope for dinner at the revived Green Room tonight…

    @ 2:49 pm on August 25, 2010
  110. Antares.

    Just kidding.

    @ 3:55 pm on August 25, 2010
  111. Kitchen 1924

    @ 4:12 pm on August 25, 2010
  112. Beau Nash!!!! I miss it dearly. San Simeon (the old triangle of Sam’s Cafe, Sfuzzi and San Simeon), and a second nod to Blue’s Lake Front across from Bachman Lake.

    @ 4:34 pm on August 25, 2010
  113. 1. Holy Smokes BBQ
    2. Hola!

    @ 5:17 pm on August 25, 2010
  114. Routh Street and Savino’s

    @ 8:26 pm on August 25, 2010
  115. Baby Routh
    Terelli’s
    8.0′s
    Riviera
    Sfuzzi

    @ 11:13 am on August 26, 2010
  116. Anzu!! Miss it!

    @ 11:21 am on August 26, 2010
  117. Callauds
    Barclays
    Lola
    Watel’s – the original location way down on McKinney
    Going Gourment(bad name good food)- where Suze is
    Wow forgot about Savino on Henderson
    The original On the Border on Knox
    Knox Street Pub (bar)
    The original PoPolos
    Dalts on Lovers where Cafe Express is
    The mussels from Routh Street Brewery
    The Green Room- wine me dine me

    @ 3:32 pm on August 27, 2010
  118. Pierre’s on the Lake
    Vincent’s on Midway
    Cappuccino on Midway-LBJ, good food, drinks, music, and dancing.

    All were great “go to” spots for many “first dates”.

    And almost forgot, Prince of Hamburgers, on Lemmon, the perfect hamburger and root beer.

    @ 3:51 pm on August 27, 2010
  119. Prince’s
    Liberty Noodles
    Alo
    Voltaire!
    Salve
    Il Sole
    FIrehouse on greenville ave
    Big D’s Dogs
    Lone Star Oyster bar on Greenville
    Hurricane Grill for Sunday Funday

    @ 4:44 pm on August 31, 2010
  120. I loved the lunch buffet at Der Schnapps and Schnacks on Northwest Highway by Bachman Lake circa 1980-1983, also Mother Tucker’s on Composite near Walnut Hill and Harry Hines in the same period.

    @ 1:29 am on September 6, 2010