14 comments on “Tuesday Afternoon Question: What’s Your Favorite Girl Scout Cookie?

  1. I alternate Do-Si-Dos with Thin Mints. My little Girl Scout came through big for me this weekend.

  2. That’s like naming a favorite child.

    Tagalongs, Samoas and Do-Si-Dos. Can’t choose.

    Oh, but frozen Thin Mints are awesome, especially with mint chocolate chip ice cream between.

    WHY did I decide to give up sweets for Lent???

  3. this is a terrible question to pose to the people. it’s like saying what’s the best pizza or burger in town. It all depends on what mood you’re in.

    Sometimes you’re in the mood for something thin – like Louies/Burger House/Thin Mint. Sometimes you want something with some substance with all the toppings – Campisi’s/Goff’s/Samoas. etc.

    There just CAN’T be a BEST all around, only a BEST FOR THE MOMENT.

  4. I just tried their newest ones… creme de caramel (maybe?)
    Nope, here:

    “Dulce de Leche: New for 2009, and inspired by the classic confections of Latin America, these sweet, indulgent cookies are rich with milk caramel chips and stripes.”

    don’t even think of eating them without dipping one (or six) in your Sunday morning coffee.

    YUM!